>
SRF Walrus
Mt. Washington, Ca
Open discussions about SRF
Gold Community SRF Walrus
    > Other websites and information
        > "Trilogy of Divine Love" controversy
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author Comment
willy1080
Registered User
(2/26/02 7:51 am)
Reply
"Trilogy of Divine Love" controversy
Taken from another message board :

-------------------------------------------------------

Quote:



Hi,

i have read this message in the Srf message board. Someone have some comment about that?

--------------------------------------

Questions about the book "Trilogy of Divine Love" have been recently asked, and I have a pertinent one that I haven't found the answer for. In the first (1992/1993) edition of the Trilogy, and before the Table of Contents, there are copies of three handwritten letters with a typed version next to each. Two of these letters are from Dr. M. W. Lewis and Brother Sarolananda. I compared the original handwritten versions with the typed counterpart of the 2 letters and found the following:

In Dr. Lewis' letter the following typed paragraphs DO NOT EXIST in the original handwritten letter:

"I cannot forget your sacrifices with the Master in the early days. Also how you built the churches and of course the hermitage and other projects. But to carry out Master's orders as to putting the Fellowship on a solid foundation, was your greatest victory. I know it was a very difficult assignment--but you did it--and that is what counts. You have done an invaluable service to all of your brothers and sisters, everywhere.

"I have one suggestion--that you now rest a little more from your labors, which is certainly in order--you have done so much.

"Once more Durga, thank you for pouring oil on troubled waters, by your gesture, born of the Divine Love in you. If there is anything I can do, you know, all you have to do is ask."

And in Brother Sarolananda's letter, here are a few EXTRAS that are not reflected in the original:

"...and I know I can stand unshaken amidst the crash of breaking worlds. My only ambition is to serve in a humble way and give God and Master's love and hope and encouragement to those that I can.

"My heart has gone out to you, for I know you have not had an easy time of it. But you may take comfort from the fact that out of those few pure and true souls who are willing to suffer misunderstandings and persecution, does God make His saints, and enfold in His Love.

"Had it not been for your long years of faithful and devoted service to Rajasi and Master, SRF might not now be in the stable financial condition it enjoys.

"I salute you and send you my love and tell you that we are one. One in God, Master's Rajasi's & Dr.'s love, and the love of all those that love God."


Since the handwritten and typed versions are placed side by side, it is easy to see and compare the two. My question is: Why were these extras added to the original? And if only two pages of the book have such huge discrepancy, is it likely that the book has more of them? I am in no way questioning the credibility and integrity of Durga Mata who was a great disciple of the Guru. After all she did not publish the book. Perhaps someone can enlighten me regarding this matter.

idf
Kare

---------------------------------------




No Name Yet
Unregistered User
(2/27/02 6:03 pm)
Reply
@#%$ ackwards
Kare says:
My question is: Why were these extras added to the original?

-------
This is like going down the street in a car and saying "Daddy, why is the land around us moving?"

Look at the book, and you'll see the "extras" were not ADDED to the original. The "extras" were snipped out of the original.

Sheesh...

rollingstone
Registered User
(3/1/02 5:05 pm)
Reply
Re: @#%$ ackwards
Yes You With NO Name

I think I know what Kare is trying to insinuate, but the obvious has escaped him/her. The letters were too long to fit on the page so the editor simply sip a paragraph out. I read some of the postings on this topic on the SRF message board and could not help getting a smile out of it. I have always sensed an underlying paranoia with that group.

Edited by: rollingstone at: 3/1/02 5:07:03 pm
premdas
Registered User
(3/7/02 10:20 pm)
Reply
Durga Ma
My understanding and feeling in reading the other sites "Divine Trilogy" "controversy is this:

Durga's writings are not authorized and therefore threatening.

Her diary contains inside first-hand accounts and are disturbing to those who want to see Yogananda in their own (or others') fantasy.

Her reminiscents (sp?) show Master's humaness, and again threaten to create discrepencies within the mind of shallower devotees (is there judgement here?)

I find it very interesting that so many wanted to attack this book! It is one of about 5 by direct disciples that I treasure most (see threads on Durga elsewhere on Walrus) for their beautiful portrayal of our Guru. And then, some attack Joan as being personally circumspect in her efforts. She edited the book as best as she could with very limited funds and very little time (she was rushing to get Durga to see it in book form before her passing).

Durga was a very strong soul. She personally served Master & Rajarsi for many years. She was not quiet. She is considered to be one of Master's dearest. She shot from the hip, while subduing her ego (read the book!)

And she remains not quiet in death, either. Her energy still stirs them up! Go Ma!

wholetruth
Registered User
(10/13/02 11:06 am)
Reply
Re: Durga Ma
I have had a recent very bad experience with trying to order this book. I sent Joan Wight Publications a check at the beginning of July. My check was cashed a few weeks later.
To date I have not received the book. About a month ago I sent a note to the P.O.Box address, requesting an explanation, and it was ignored.

Joan Wight has no listed phone number or e-mail address. I am mystified by the situation and don't know what to think. Does anyone know her?

Edited by: wholetruth at: 10/14/02 6:52:18 am
srflongago
Registered User
(10/13/02 12:41 pm)
Reply
Re: Durga Ma
Joan Wight is a very nice person. She lived with Ma Durga as disciple and friend for many years. She also spent previously many years at SRF; having spent much of her youth there. She is upset this several weeks due to being subpoenaed for testimony in the everlasting suit of SRF against Ananda about her collection of over 700 letters from Lynn which she deposited years ago at the Library of Congress. I have lost my e-mail address book and your email address. If you e-mail me yours, I will send you her phone number. If you have lost mine, I have an account also as forwardloooking2003@yahoo.com.

premdas
Registered User
(10/13/02 2:56 pm)
Reply
Re: Joan Wight
In addition to answering the above-mentioned query, the present discussion provokes this true story. May you receive some joy from my telling it:

I met Joan Wight while I was teaching Yoga at an out-of-the-way retreat/spa back around 1995. She was most kind and helpful, extremely peaceful, calm and quietly magnetic. Our meeting was synchronistic with my then devotee's desire of wishing I had an opportunity to actually have my guru's (Yogananda) physical presence, which I of course realized was quite physically unlikely. I was glad to meet someone who I felt had direct lineage to the man I regarded as my exemplar.
Ms. Wight was then traveling and promoting Durga's book, which I was currently reading, having just obtained it 2 weeks earlier through the boutique at the Expanding Light Retreat at Ananda. She was curious about me as she and an associate had noticed my outdoor class and the instructions to yoga students, specifically my explanation of the energization techniques/rechargers; she wanted to know what my background was. At the time I was actively involved w/ SRF and Ananda (just a devotee sharing....) When I explained my discipleship to her, she laughed and said, "oh, an Ananda man!". She listened to my inquiries about her and Durga, she surprisingly noting my knowledge of the diaries and my almost rabid interest as a chela of Yogananda's. I passingly explained to her my wistful aforementioned "desire", and our conversation continued into how I could help direct her to the local book buyers, who I knew quite well (I unofficially would keep tabs on all Yogananda related books in our area, convincing bookbuyers to reorder or initiatiate purchases of new releases, no matter who the publisher. I kept the sections on Master quite presentable and organized, often magnetizing increasing sales!) When it was time to take our leave, she looked deep in my eyes and said to wait a few moments. When she returned, I was waiting by my car in the parking lot. It was a very windy day. She held out her hand to me and gave me a tissue, explaining not to open it then, the contents would be swept away. then she told me she felt that I was supposed to have this, that it would serve me and my devotions and the work I was doing to share Yogananda's mission of yoga and self-realization. Her words were salve for my then situation and life changes. She had given me a lock of my guru's hair, telling me that Durga had brushed Master's hair throughout her days of service and had saved the hairs from the brushing. Joan said I was to have this. I saw it as the manifestation of my deepest desire and the fruition of my guru's grace. (I often humorously wonder if srf would ever claim legal ownership!). I honor and carry this relic with me everywhere. In my opinion, she is very honorable and a sincere seeker.

I suggest we pray for her and all others (ourselves included) who are involved in the sad never-ending litigation and religious persecution that have become the hallmark of this SRF Board. God bless them, too, and correct their blind and evil ways. If they could only feel the hurts they continue to cause good seekers; this is why I can't believe any talk of Daya's or others's realization.

In service, Premdas

srflongago
Registered User
(10/13/02 4:02 pm)
Reply
Re: Joan Wight
Thank you for telling our little group more about Joan. She is a very fine, very spiritual person.

pilgrim
Registered User
(10/13/02 4:32 pm)
Reply
Re: Joan Wight
Wholetruth

I waited for months for my book also, and had given up on it, it eventually turned up with a lovely note of apology for the lengthy delay.

It is a book worth having, and worth the wait.

:o ) pilgrim

member108
Registered User
(10/13/02 5:42 pm)
Reply
Re: Joan Wight
I would also like to comment that Joan is a good person. Her work with that book has caused her problems with SRF. She is on their black list big time and they spread rumors about her as a result. I am sure there are other explainations for the delay. I would suggest writing her again?

Lobo
Registered User
(10/13/02 9:15 pm)
Reply
Re: Durga Ma
Whole Truth,

If you're looking to get the book quickly I saw it at the Bodhi Tree bookstore in West Hollywood. They seemed to have a good supply of not only Ma Durga's book but Dr. Lewis' and Kamala's as well.

www.bodhitree.com/

I have spoken on the phone with Joan. She is a very fine person who is wholeheartedly devoted to PY and Ma Durga. She has endured years of threats from SRF, legal hassles that she told me caused her to use the equity in her home to fight (she's not wealthy, worked for the city as a secretary for years, now retired) them with. She's the repository of Ma Durga's writings and as SRFlongago says Rajasi's correspondence.

wholetruth
Registered User
(10/14/02 5:57 pm)
Reply
Re: Joan Wight
Thanks to everyone for coming to Joan Wight's defense. I definitely misjudged her and the situation. Thanks also for your patience with me. I sort of sounded like a jerk, but no one said so.

Srflongago gave me her phone number, and I called and left a message. Within the past hour she returned my call. She explained that she had been waiting for a new cover to be made, and it was just completed so she would be sending my book out this week. She apologized for the delay and for not informing me of the situation. You are all correct. She's a very lovely person, and she even told me some stories of Ma Durga while on the phone.

That SRF harasses and persecutes people like her is a real crime.

chuckle chela
Registered User
(10/18/02 8:07 pm)
Reply
Re: Update on the SRF-Ananda lawsuit?
Premdas or srflongago--can either of you (or anyone else) update us on the lawsuit? Any interesting developments or just the same old, dragging-on-forever-to-bankrupt-Ananda? And I wondered about the 700 Lynn letters--is SRF trying to claim ownership or copyright on these? I presume that since they are in the Library of Congress they are either in the public domain or copyrighted to Joan Wight--is this correct?

Thanks for any info.

srflongago
Registered User
(10/19/02 3:35 am)
Reply
Re: Update on the SRF-Ananda lawsuit?
I heard that Ananda, not SRF, asked her to testify after they had read the Lynn letters at the Library of Congress.

They must have felt that the letters would help defeat SRF's claim that SRF inherited Yogananda's intellectual property rights.

But I have also heard that the SRF-Ananda suit is supposed to be decided about now. If so, she will not be called to testify in person.

However, for many years SRF has exercised great ingenuity, always finding new grounds for extending that suit. I ascribe to the creed of that most famous of Yogis, Yogi Berra: "It ain't over till its over".

Edited by: srflongago at: 10/19/02 5:49:31 am
Lobo
Registered User
(10/19/02 9:24 pm)
Reply
Re: Update on the SRF-Ananda lawsuit?
Any chance that we could log onto the Library of Congress and pull up those letters?

I once logged on to that site and punched in Parmahansa Yogananda and a whole slew of stuff came up, most of it writings from his books.

Anyone with better computer skills than mine care to see if they can come up with the letters? If found it would be great to have those uncensored letters, wouldn't it?

Another question. Was Joan asked to give a deposition or testify at trial?

An exemption from the normal timeframe (it lengthens by 20 years) of a copyright exists for certain writings and films. It was a special extension of time granted by an act of Congress. A case was argued recently before the Supreme Court seeking to end this exemption, no decision yet. I wonder if this exemption has any weight upon SRF's claims. Maybe they are hoping for this exemption to copyright law to be found constitutional and therefore valid in their lawsuit claim. Anyone know?

srflongago
Registered User
(10/20/02 4:04 am)
Reply
Re: Update on the SRF-Ananda lawsuit?
The letters are in a restricted collection at the Library of Congress, which anyone visiting Washington can personally access and read there,under a watchful guard, but they are not online.

Edited by: srflongago at: 10/20/02 6:49:05 am
premdas
Registered User
(10/22/02 4:36 pm)
Reply
Re: Update on the SRF-Ananda lawsuit?
I'm sorry for the delay in answering you, Chch; I've been taking seclusion this past week -- a fellow poster told me you'd started this question.

At this time, everyone please keep Master's teachings and all gurubais in your prayers. More will have to wait.

In Dharma is Victory

Premdas

Edited by: premdas at: 10/23/02 9:47:14 am
<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- SRF Walrus - Other websites and information -



Powered By ezboardŽ Ver. 7.32
Copyright Š1999-2005 ezboard, Inc.